Would like to see this change made
I'd like to see this changed in our oDesk profiles....
When a buyer (or anyone else surfing public profiles) clicks on a Provider's profile he or she can view the charge (hourly) rates for previous or ongoing jobs that the Provider is currently working on or has worked on. It is no one's business but my own what I am getting paid to do a job. I consider this personal information in the same way my Social Insurance (Social Security in the U.S.) number is personal information.
If you were working for a non-virtual company and got your pay by paper check - the check would be sealed in an envelope for each individual employee. In some retail jobs I've had - it was forbidden to even disclose your rate of pay to co-workers. I mean a complete stranger came up to you and asked "how much money do you make a year?" you would tell them it's none of their business, right? This is the same thing in my opinion.
The following proves my point (I think)
I got an interview invitation from a Buyer yesterday. In his job description he advertised that he wanted someone to do the work for less than $15 per hour. My charge rate is consistently $10 an hour - and that's what I bid on his project. I have been doing similar work for another Buyer since last November and it was only my second oDesk job. My charge rate at that time was $8.50 an hour and this Buyer and I are currently negotiating a raise, since I now have "certification" for the project and because we've worked together for a year. The Buyer who contacted me about this new position said...and I quote..."We also want you to work for us below $10 as you are already working on the similar type of work below $10." It's not going to happen. This Buyer obviously looked on my profile and saw that I was doing similar work for a lesser price and so now doesn't want to pay my bid rate.
The only thing a Buyer needs to know is a Provider's qualifications, education and experience in order to determine whether or not the Provider is a good fit for the position.
I don't want my "earnings" displayed for the world to see. Even putting your profile on "Private" is not a solution, because any Buyer inviting you for an interview can still see your earnings.
Respectfully,
Debbie MacKenzie
thanks....
Debbie,
I personally agree with you. There were some extended discussions on this topic that you can read here. Doreen
Thanks Doreen,
I just had a look at them all - and posted this in there too - still feel the same about it.
Debbie
I agree with Debbie-- our income should be PRIVATE
Debbie, you are absolutely right. In the USA, income is always considered a private matter, and oDesk should give us the option to keep our financial information PRIVATE.
Agree
I agree, I have actually even not bid on certain projects because of that reason. When you start out you always start lower as you experience you can start asking more but if everybody can see your pay history you will get situations like you were in. That's not right. Off course some buyers might understand you have more experience now and see your point but many might not.
Update
I agree, I have actually even not bid on certain projects because of that reason. When you start out you always start lower as you experience you can start asking more but if everybody can see your pay history you will get situations like you were in. That's not right. Off course some buyers might understand you have more experience now and see your point but many might not.
Exactly!
And to update you all on this scenario. I wrote the Buyer and told him I wasn't willing to drop my hourly price because I now had a year of experience doing this type of work as well as official certification.
He hired me.
However I still don't want my personal financial information on display for the world to see. I can freelance on my own without the benefit oDesk, if need be, it would just take some time and work to market my skills to the virtual world. If this doesn't change that's exactly what I'll be doing.
DM
Please continue the
on Thu, 2008-11-06 05:39.Please continue the discussion in this thread.
Regards,
Olga
I agree with you
Debbie,
I personally agree with you. There were some extended discussions on this topic that you can read here. Doreen